The Ultimate Comparison: Natural and Traditional Swimming Pools

Unveiling the Ultimate Guide to Swimming in Natural Pools: Your Gateway to Natural Swimming Pools

Table of Contents

Swimming pools have become an integral part of outdoor recreation and living. However, when it comes to choosing a pool, the options have been limited to natural or traditional pools, each with its own set of advantages and disadvantages. This article explores the viewpoints of four different types of people:


to help you understand the differences between natural and traditional pools, allowing you to make an informed decision.

Environmental Advocates Perspective

Cheltenham - completed

Natural swimming pools are viewed positively by environmental activists because they rely on natural filtration systems. These systems use plants and bacteria to keep the water clean without chemical treatment, which reduces the impact on the environment and makes the water safer for swimming. Additionally, natural pools are designed to blend in with the surrounding nature, preserving and promoting biodiversity. However, they may require more maintenance and can be more expensive to construct. Click here for more information on eco-friendly swimming pools.

Traditional swimming pools, on the other hand, have a convenient and efficient filtration system. They can also be smaller and more suitable for smaller spaces, offering a conventional swimming experience. However, high water and chemical usage can harm the environment, and the chemicals used to treat the water can be harmful and irritating to the eyes and skin.

Natural Swimming Pools

Pros

  • Rely on natural filtration systems, such as plants and bacteria, to maintain clean water without the need for chemical treatment
  • Reduce the impact on the environment and make the water safer for swimming
  • Designed to blend in with the surrounding nature, preserving and promoting biodiversity


Cons

  • May require more maintenance than traditional pools
  • May be more expensive to construct and install


Traditional Swimming Pools

Pros

  • Convenient and efficient filtration system
  • Can be smaller and more suitable for smaller spaces
  • Offer a conventional swimming experience


Cons

  • High water and chemical usage, which can harm the environment
  • Chemicals used to treat the water can be harmful to the environment and irritating to the eyes and skin

Pond Life Species Found in Different Regions of the UK and Ireland

RegionAmphibiansInsectsFishPlants
North East EnglandGreat Crested Newt, Common Frog, Smooth Newt, Common ToadWater Boatman, Water Scorpion, Pond Skater, Whirligig Beetle, Water Stick Insect, Water BeetleNorthern Pike, RuddCommon Reed, Water Lilies, Water Crowfoot, Yellow Water Lily, Marsh Marigold, Water Plantain, Water Forget-me-not, Purple Loosestrife, Marsh Pennywort, Bogbean, Brooklime, Water Speedwell
North West EnglandGreat Crested Newt, Common Frog, Smooth Newt, Common ToadWater Boatman, Water Scorpion, Pond Skater, Whirligig Beetle, Water Stick Insect, Water BeetleNorthern Pike, RuddCommon Reed, Water Lilies, Water Crowfoot, Yellow Water Lily, Marsh Marigold, Water Plantain, Water Forget-me-not, Purple Loosestrife, Marsh Pennywort, Bogbean, Brooklime
Yorkshire and the HumberGreat Crested Newt, Common Frog, Smooth Newt, Common ToadWater Boatman, Water Scorpion, Pond Skater, Whirligig Beetle, Water Stick Insect, Water Beetle, Damselfly, DragonflyTench, Roach, BreamCommon Reed, Water Lilies, Water Crowfoot, Yellow Water Lily, Marsh Marigold, Water Plantain, Water Forget-me-not, Purple Loosestrife, Marsh Pennywort, Bogbean, Brooklime, Water Speedwell
East MidlandsGreat Crested Newt, Common Frog, Smooth Newt, Common ToadWater Boatman, Water Scorpion, Pond Skater, Whirligig Beetle, Water Stick Insect, Water Beetle, Damselfly, DragonflyTench, Roach, BreamWater Crowfoot, Yellow Water Lily, Water Plantain, Marsh Pennywort, Purple Loosestrife, Bogbean, Brooklime, Greater Spearwort, Water Avens, Marsh Woundwort
West MidlandsGreat Crested Newt, Common Frog, Smooth Newt, Common ToadWater Boatman, Water Scorpion, Pond Skater, Whirligig Beetle, Water Stick Insect, Water Beetle, Damselfly, DragonflyCommon Carp, Mirror Carp, Tench, Roach, BreamCommon Reed, Water Lilies, Yellow Flag Iris, Great Willowherb, Marsh Marigold, Water Plantain, Water Forget-me-not, Purple Loosestrife, Marsh Pennywort, Bogbean, Brooklime
East of EnglandGreat Crested Newt, Common Frog, Smooth Newt, Common ToadWater Boatman, Water Scorpion, Pond Skater, Whirligig Beetle, Water Stick Insect, Water Beetle, Damselfly, DragonflyRudd, Common Bream, Roach, PerchCommon Reed, Yellow Water Lily, Water Crowfoot, Water Mint, Brooklime, Bogbean, Water Figwort, Greater Spearwort, Lesser Spearwort
LondonGreat Crested Newt, Common Frog, Smooth Newt, Common ToadWater Boatman, Water Scorpion, Pond Skater, Whirligig Beetle, Water Stick Insect, Water Beetle, Damselfly, DragonflyCarp, Rudd, Perch, RoachCommon Reed, Water Lilies, Yellow Flag Iris, Water Forget-me-not, Great Willowherb, Brook
South East EnglandGreat Crested Newt, Common Frog, Smooth Newt, Common ToadWater Boatman, Water Scorpion, Pond Skater, Whirligig Beetle, Water Stick Insect, Water Beetle, Damselfly, DragonflyCommon Carp, Rudd, Perch, Roach, Tench, BreamCommon Reed, Yellow Water Lily, Water Crowfoot, Water Forget-me-not, Greater Spearwort, Lesser Spearwort, Brooklime, Water Figwort, Fool’s Watercress, Mare’s-tail, Marsh Marigold, Purple Loosestrife
South West EnglandGreat Crested Newt, Common Frog, Smooth Newt, Common ToadWater Boatman, Water Scorpion, Pond Skater, Whirligig Beetle, Water Stick Insect, Water Beetle, Damselfly, DragonflyTench, Perch, Roach, BreamCommon Reed, Yellow Water Lily, Water Crowfoot, Water Forget-me-not, Greater Spearwort, Lesser Spearwort, Brooklime, Water Figwort, Fool’s Watercress, Mare’s-tail, Marsh Marigold, Purple Loosestrife, Yellow Flag Iris
WalesGreat Crested Newt, Common Frog, Smooth Newt, Common ToadWater Boatman, Water Scorpion, Pond Skater, Whirligig Beetle, Water Stick Insect, Water Beetle, Damselfly, DragonflyTench, Bream, Brown Trout, PikeCommon Reed, Yellow Water Lily, Water Crowfoot, Water Forget-me-not, Greater Spearwort, Lesser Spearwort, Brooklime, Water Figwort, Fool’s Watercress, Mare’s-tail, Marsh Marigold, Purple Loosestrife, Yellow Flag Iris
ScotlandGreat Crested Newt, Common Frog, Smooth Newt, Common ToadWater Boatman, Water Scorpion, Pond Skater, Whirligig Beetle, Water Stick Insect, Water Beetle, Damselfly, DragonflyBrown Trout, Pike, Perch, RoachBogbean, Brooklime, Bulrush, Marsh Marigold, Water Crowfoot, Yellow Water Lily, Yellow Flag Iris, Purple Loosestrife
Northern IrelandGreat Crested Newt, Common Frog, Smooth Newt, Common ToadWater Boatman, Water Scorpion, Pond Skater, Whirligig Beetle, Water Stick Insect, Water Beetle, Damselfly, DragonflyBrown Trout, Pike, RoachBogbean, Brooklime, Bulrush, Marsh Marigold, Water Crowfoot, Yellow Water Lily, Yellow Flag Iris, Purple Loosestrife, Greater Spearwort
Isle of ManCommon Frog, Common ToadWater Boatman, Water Scorpion, Pond Skater, Whirligig Beetle, Water Stick Insect, Water Beetle, Damselfly, DragonflyBrown Trout, Pike, Perch, RoachWater Crowfoot, Yellow Water Lily, Greater Spearwort, Lesser Spearwort, Marsh Marigold, Purple Loosestrife
Channel IslandsCommon Frog, Agile FrogWater Boatman, Water Scorpion, Pond Skater, Whirligig Beetle, Water Stick Insect, Water Beetle, Damselfly, DragonflyBrown Trout, Pike, Perch, RoachWater Crowfoot, Yellow Water Lily, Marsh Marigold, Purple Loosestrife
IrelandNatterjack Toad, Common Frog, Smooth Newt, Common ToadWater Boatman, Water Scorpion, Pond Skater, Whirligig Beetle, Water Stick Insect, Water Beetle, Damselfly, DragonflyBrown Trout, Pike, Perch, RoachBogbean, Brooklime, Bulrush, Marsh Marigold, Water Crowfoot, Yellow Water Lily, Yellow Flag Iris, Purple Loosestrife, Greater Spearwort

Health Enthusiast’s Perspective

Girl from behind swimming in a lake in the summer
Swimming in a natural pond

From a fitness enthusiast perspective, natural swimming pools offer several advantages. They provide more space for activities such as swimming, diving, and water aerobics. The natural currents and resistance provided by the water plants and bacteria can also enhance cardiovascular fitness. Furthermore, natural pools are safe for swimming without exposure to harmful chemicals. However, they may require more maintenance and can be more expensive to construct. Learn more about the benefits of natural swimming pools here.

Traditional swimming pools, while offering a convenient and efficient filtration system, can be limiting for fitness enthusiasts. They are often smaller and more suitable for smaller spaces, but this can limit the available space for activities such as swimming and diving. Additionally, the chemicals used to treat the water can be irritating to the eyes and skin, potentially causing discomfort during a workout.

Natural Swimming Pools

Pros

  • Offer more space for activities such as swimming, diving, and water aerobics
  • Natural currents and resistance provided by the water plants and bacteria can enhance cardiovascular fitness
  • Safe for swimming without exposure to harmful chemicals


Cons

  • May require more maintenance than traditional pools
  • Can be more expensive to construct and install


Traditional Swimming Pools

Pros

  • Convenient and efficient filtration system
  • Often smaller and more suitable for smaller spaces
  • Offer a conventional swimming experience


Cons

  • Chemicals used to treat the water can be irritating to the eyes and skin
  • Limited in space for activities such as swimming and diving

Health reasons why natural swimming pools work
Print this infographic today by downloading the PDF version here
Dog (labrador retriever) shaking water after swimming in pond at sunset.
Labrador enjoying a swim in a natural pond at sunset

From a pet lover’s viewpoint, natural swimming pools offer several benefits. They are designed with shallow areas, making it easier for pets to enter and exit the water. The natural filtration system also ensures that the water is safe for pets to swim in without exposing them to harmful chemicals. Additionally, natural pools offer a pet-friendly environment. However, they may require more maintenance and can be more expensive to construct. Click here to learn more about natural swimming pools for pets.

Traditional swimming pools, while offering a convenient and efficient filtration system, can be challenging for pets. The chemicals used to treat the water can be harmful to pets if ingested, posing a potential risk to their health. Additionally, traditional pools can be difficult for pets to navigate, making them less accessible and less enjoyable for furry friends. Furthermore, they are often smaller and more suitable for smaller spaces, which can limit the available swimming area for pets.

Natural Swimming Pools

Pros

  • Designed with shallow areas, making it easier for pets to enter and exit the water
  • Natural filtration system ensures the water is safe for pets to swim in without exposing them to harmful chemicals
  • Offer a pet-friendly environment


Cons

  • May require more maintenance than traditional pools
  • Can be more expensive to construct and install


Traditional Swimming Pools

Pros

  • Convenient and efficient filtration system
  • Often smaller and more suitable for smaller spaces
  • Offer a conventional swimming experience


Cons

  • Chemicals used to treat the water can be harmful to pets if ingested
  • Can be difficult for pets to navigate


Learning Enthusiasts’ Perspective

From a learning enthusiast’s point of view, natural swimming pools provide a wealth of educational opportunities. They promote exploration and hands-on learning experiences with plants, bacteria, and aquatic life, as well as fostering a connection between nature and the environment. In addition, natural pools offer a safe and chemical-free environment for children to learn and play. The main downside to these pools is that they may require more maintenance and be costlier to construct. Learn more about the educational benefits of natural swimming pools here.

On the other hand, traditional swimming pools may offer a more conventional swimming experience, with a convenient and efficient filtration system. They are often smaller and more suitable for smaller spaces, but they limit learning opportunities compared to natural pools. Moreover, the chemicals used to treat the water in traditional pools can be harmful to the environment and human health.

Natural Swimming Pools

Pros

  • Offer a unique learning opportunity to understand and appreciate the connection between nature and the environment
  • Encourages exploration and hands-on learning experiences with plants, bacteria, and aquatic life
  • Provides a safe and chemical-free environment for children to learn and play


Cons

  • May require more maintenance than traditional pools
  • Can be more expensive to construct and install


Traditional Swimming Pools

Pros

  • Offer a conventional swimming experience
  • Convenient and efficient filtration system
  • Often smaller and more suitable for smaller spaces


Cons

  • Limited learning opportunities compared to natural pools
  • Chemicals used to treat the water can be harmful to the environment and the health of those who use the pool



In conclusion, the choice between a natural or traditional swimming pool depends on various factors, including personal preference, budget, and the intended use of the pool. Natural pools are an excellent option for those who prioritise sustainability and eco-friendliness, while traditional pools may be more convenient for those with limited space or a smaller budget.

Regardless of which type of pool you choose, it’s essential to maintain proper water chemistry and hygiene to ensure a safe and enjoyable swimming experience for everyone.

Overall, swimming pools provide a great way to enjoy the outdoors and stay active, and the decision to choose a natural or traditional pool ultimately comes down to your individual needs and preferences.

Ready to take the plunge and enjoy the benefits of a natural swimming pool? Contact Landmarc today to get started on creating your very own garden oasis. Our experienced team will work with you to design a custom natural swimming pool that fits your unique style and needs. Don’t wait any longer, get in touch with us now for a quote!

´╗┐RegionAmphibiansInsectsFishPlants
North East EnglandGreat Crested Newt, Common Frog, Smooth Newt, Common ToadWater Boatman, Water Scorpion, Pond Skater, Whirligig Beetle, Water Stick Insect, Water BeetleNorthern Pike, RuddCommon Reed, Water Lilies, Water Crowfoot, Yellow Water Lily, Marsh Marigold, Water Plantain, Water Forget-me-not, Purple Loosestrife, Marsh Pennywort, Bogbean, Brooklime, Water Speedwell
North West EnglandGreat Crested Newt, Common Frog, Smooth Newt, Common ToadWater Boatman, Water Scorpion, Pond Skater, Whirligig Beetle, Water Stick Insect, Water BeetleNorthern Pike, RuddCommon Reed, Water Lilies, Water Crowfoot, Yellow Water Lily, Marsh Marigold, Water Plantain, Water Forget-me-not, Purple Loosestrife, Marsh Pennywort, Bogbean, Brooklime
Yorkshire and the HumberGreat Crested Newt, Common Frog, Smooth Newt, Common ToadWater Boatman, Water Scorpion, Pond Skater, Whirligig Beetle, Water Stick Insect, Water Beetle, Damselfly, DragonflyTench, Roach, BreamCommon Reed, Water Lilies, Water Crowfoot, Yellow Water Lily, Marsh Marigold, Water Plantain, Water Forget-me-not, Purple Loosestrife, Marsh Pennywort, Bogbean, Brooklime, Water Speedwell
East MidlandsGreat Crested Newt, Common Frog, Smooth Newt, Common ToadWater Boatman, Water Scorpion, Pond Skater, Whirligig Beetle, Water Stick Insect, Water Beetle, Damselfly, DragonflyTench, Roach, BreamWater Crowfoot, Yellow Water Lily, Water Plantain, Marsh Pennywort, Purple Loosestrife, Bogbean, Brooklime, Greater Spearwort, Water Avens, Marsh Woundwort
West MidlandsGreat Crested Newt, Common Frog, Smooth Newt, Common ToadWater Boatman, Water Scorpion, Pond Skater, Whirligig Beetle, Water Stick Insect, Water Beetle, Damselfly, DragonflyCommon Carp, Mirror Carp, Tench, Roach, BreamCommon Reed, Water Lilies, Yellow Flag Iris, Great Willowherb, Marsh Marigold, Water Plantain, Water Forget-me-not, Purple Loosestrife, Marsh Pennywort, Bogbean, Brooklime
East of EnglandGreat Crested Newt, Common Frog, Smooth Newt, Common ToadWater Boatman, Water Scorpion, Pond Skater, Whirligig Beetle, Water Stick Insect, Water Beetle, Damselfly, DragonflyRudd, Common Bream, Roach, PerchCommon Reed, Yellow Water Lily, Water Crowfoot, Water Mint, Brooklime, Bogbean, Water Figwort, Greater Spearwort, Lesser Spearwort
LondonGreat Crested Newt, Common Frog, Smooth Newt, Common ToadWater Boatman, Water Scorpion, Pond Skater, Whirligig Beetle, Water Stick Insect, Water Beetle, Damselfly, DragonflyCarp, Rudd, Perch, RoachCommon Reed, Water Lilies, Yellow Flag Iris, Water Forget-me-not, Great Willowherb, Brook
South East EnglandGreat Crested Newt, Common Frog, Smooth Newt, Common ToadWater Boatman, Water Scorpion, Pond Skater, Whirligig Beetle, Water Stick Insect, Water Beetle, Damselfly, DragonflyCommon Carp, Rudd, Perch, Roach, Tench, BreamCommon Reed, Yellow Water Lily, Water Crowfoot, Water Forget-me-not, Greater Spearwort, Lesser Spearwort, Brooklime, Water Figwort, Fool’s Watercress, Mare’s-tail, Marsh Marigold, Purple Loosestrife
South West EnglandGreat Crested Newt, Common Frog, Smooth Newt, Common ToadWater Boatman, Water Scorpion, Pond Skater, Whirligig Beetle, Water Stick Insect, Water Beetle, Damselfly, DragonflyTench, Perch, Roach, BreamCommon Reed, Yellow Water Lily, Water Crowfoot, Water Forget-me-not, Greater Spearwort, Lesser Spearwort, Brooklime, Water Figwort, Fool’s Watercress, Mare’s-tail, Marsh Marigold, Purple Loosestrife, Yellow Flag Iris
WalesGreat Crested Newt, Common Frog, Smooth Newt, Common ToadWater Boatman, Water Scorpion, Pond Skater, Whirligig Beetle, Water Stick Insect, Water Beetle, Damselfly, DragonflyTench, Bream, Brown Trout, PikeCommon Reed, Yellow Water Lily, Water Crowfoot, Water Forget-me-not, Greater Spearwort, Lesser Spearwort, Brooklime, Water Figwort, Fool’s Watercress, Mare’s-tail, Marsh Marigold, Purple Loosestrife, Yellow Flag Iris
ScotlandGreat Crested Newt, Common Frog, Smooth Newt, Common ToadWater Boatman, Water Scorpion, Pond Skater, Whirligig Beetle, Water Stick Insect, Water Beetle, Damselfly, DragonflyBrown Trout, Pike, Perch, RoachBogbean, Brooklime, Bulrush, Marsh Marigold, Water Crowfoot, Yellow Water Lily, Yellow Flag Iris, Purple Loosestrife
Northern IrelandGreat Crested Newt, Common Frog, Smooth Newt, Common ToadWater Boatman, Water Scorpion, Pond Skater, Whirligig Beetle, Water Stick Insect, Water Beetle, Damselfly, DragonflyBrown Trout, Pike, RoachBogbean, Brooklime, Bulrush, Marsh Marigold, Water Crowfoot, Yellow Water Lily, Yellow Flag Iris, Purple Loosestrife, Greater Spearwort
Isle of ManCommon Frog, Common ToadWater Boatman, Water Scorpion, Pond Skater, Whirligig Beetle, Water Stick Insect, Water Beetle, Damselfly, DragonflyBrown Trout, Pike, Perch, RoachWater Crowfoot, Yellow Water Lily, Greater Spearwort, Lesser Spearwort, Marsh Marigold, Purple Loosestrife
Channel IslandsCommon Frog, Agile FrogWater Boatman, Water Scorpion, Pond Skater, Whirligig Beetle, Water Stick Insect, Water Beetle, Damselfly, DragonflyBrown Trout, Pike, Perch, RoachWater Crowfoot, Yellow Water Lily, Marsh Marigold, Purple Loosestrife
IrelandNatterjack Toad, Common Frog, Smooth Newt, Common ToadWater Boatman, Water Scorpion, Pond Skater, Whirligig Beetle, Water Stick Insect, Water Beetle, Damselfly, DragonflyBrown Trout, Pike, Perch, RoachBogbean, Brooklime, Bulrush, Marsh Marigold, Water Crowfoot, Yellow Water Lily, Yellow Flag Iris, Purple Loosestrife, Greater Spearwort